You have contributed 0.0% of this topic
I had requested this site to provide complete answers and quote the narrations so people don't get confused. But of course they are South Africans so they know best!
Narration from Bayhaqi:
(Øديث مرÙوع) أَخْبَرَنَا أَبÙÙˆ طَاهÙر٠الْÙÙŽÙ‚Ùيه٠، أنا أَبÙÙˆ طَاهÙر٠الْمÙØَمَّدَابَادÙيّ٠، نا Ø£ÙŽØْمَد٠بْن٠يÙوسÙÙÙŽ السّÙÙ„ÙŽÙ…Ùيّ٠، نا سَعÙيد٠بْن٠سÙلَيْمَانَ ØŒ نا هَيَّاجٌ ØŒ نا عَنْبَسَة٠بْن٠عَبْد٠الرَّØْمَن٠بْن٠سَعÙيد٠بْن٠الْعَاص٠، عَنْ Ù…ÙØَمَّد٠بْن٠زَاذَانَ ØŒ عَنْ عَلÙيّ٠بْن٠ØÙسَيْن٠، عَنْ أَبÙيه٠، قال : قال رسول اللَّه٠صَلَّى اللَّه٠عَلَيْه٠وَسَلَّمَ : " مَن٠اعْتَكَÙÙŽ عَشْرًا ÙÙÙŠ رَمَضَانَ كَانَ ÙƒÙŽØَجَّتَيْن٠وَعÙمْرَتَيْن٠" . ÙˆÙŽØ¥ÙسْنَادÙه٠ضَعÙÙŠÙÙŒ وَمَا قَبْلَه٠ÙÙيه٠ضَعْÙÙŒ ØŒ وَاللَّه٠أَعْلَم٠.
In Kashful Ghummah, Allahmah Sharaani relates a Hadith wherein Rasulullah S.W. said, “Whoever performs I’itikaaf for the final ten days of Ramadhaan, for him is the reward of two Haj and two Umrahs and whoever performs I’itikaaf from Maghrib until ‘Ishaa’ doing nothing except performing ‘salaah and reciting the Qur'aan Allah will prepare a palace in Jannah”.
Its the same story with Fadhail-e-Aamaal i.e. Shaykh (RA) has not quoted any fabrications knowingly, he usually quotes on the authority of someone and others say its fabricated while the original author may think of it as weak or even extremely weak (but not fabrication).
Shaykh Zakarriya (RA) quotes on the authority of another Muhadith who doesn't think that it’s a fabrication. He (RA) then quotes it from Imam Bayhaqi (RA) who clearly didn’t label it as a fabrication.
Not quoting the narration is therefore a subjective call. Sufi or no Sufi books of Ahadeeth are filled with such narrations and unless you can prove that he quoted a fabrication deliberately it’s a “subjective call”.
I personally think Riyadus-Saliheen should be used by TJs instead of Fadhail-e-Aamaal but that’s also just my opinion.
You & I have our opinion and Shaykh Zakariyya (RA) and others disagree, not the end of the world.
This cannot be undone and I am sure it will be greatly appreciated.
Please wait...