The Fiqh, Qur’aan, Sunnah arguments of Majlis are riddled with errors. Let whoever wants to defend them come on the forum and have an open debate.
Nobody with any serious knowledge, gives weight to their opinion. They respect Hazrat for his age, seniority, Taqwa, work ethics etc which is different to Academic standing. Deobandees have problem distinguishing between many of the factors…Imam Ghazali (RA) is a great scholar but he has been questioned by Ulama in Hadeeth…Imam Muslim (RA) is a Master of Hadeeth but not a Faqih…Haji Imdadul Muhajir Makki (RA) is a giant in Tassawuff but not Muhadith or Faqih.
Hazrat (DB) is a great personality but some of his opinions are extreme, unwarranted and baseless. This is the opinion of oerhwelming majority of British and South African Ulama. They won’t say it because his influence is limited and he will tear into and eat the flesh of Scholars who disagree with him (no matter how politely).
Let one of the FANBOYS an FANGIRLS, report this post to them and let them issue a 4th Fatwa on me.
Laymen Deobandees believe that Ulama are relaxing their stance and comprising with the Baatil. They have grown up with a certain mind-set and their Manhaj is the opinion of their Akabir. In some issues that is valid, in some issues life has advanced and moved on and due to genuine reasons opinions have changed.
Differences in the application of Photography is an issue of Ijtehaad. You see Ulama give a Fatwa that photography is Haram and YET come to Britain to collect Chanda for their Madrasah.
The same "upright Ulama" who consider photography Haram travel around the world by getting VISAS for travel and deem it “necessary” thus indulge in Haram.
They don’t deem the need to defend Islam on youtube as “necessary”.
Visiting dying Aunty in Gujarat or flying to Texas to get Chanda or do Aitekaaf is necessary.
The point I am making is that actions of these “upright Ulama” tells you that the application of the matter (if not the issue itself) is based on Ijtehaad.
The reason we are in this place is because nobody has got the guts to ask these “upright Ulama” Hazrat what are your reasons for indulging in Haram by coming to London?
If you deem it necessary then why do you disagree with Maulana Tarqi Jameel’s presence on youtube when he deems it necessary.
When you question these “upright Ulama” they don’t respond to you but go into their little groups and backbite you (in your absence) because that’s all they are capable of doing. Years of study and company of Ulama have taught them to backbite people and to dishonur Muslims. This is the behavior of "reformed ones" amongst us who can speak for 2 Hours and write eloquently on facebook and Twitter about morality and Sunnah.
You are an intelligent guy, use your mind.
This cannot be undone and I am sure it will be greatly appreciated.
Please wait...
