Question ID: #4761
Question: Not sure if Mani or wadi
Assalamualaikum. My question is this.
If in wakefulness you think about stuff and madhi came out due to it, but your not sure if Mani also came out due to it, (I always have wadi so I'm not sure if it was wadi or Mani. Basically wadi came out for sure but I'm not sure if there was also Mani with it.) do you go according to what you think it is? Or is it like the ruling for if you see discharge after you wake up and you remember or don't remember seeing a wet dream -(if doubt whether it's mani or madhi or wadi, you need to take a fard shower.)?
Answered by: Ulamaa ID 04 (London)
Date: 25/04/2021 14:59pm

بسم الله الرحمن الرحيم

الجواب حامداومصليا

Wadi sometimes can be discharged without urinating. Mani can come out without desire. Hence, as they are both filthy you must wash those parts of the body or clothing which has been soiled with filth. If however, there was desire then Ghusl will be compulsory.

إن الودي مايخرج بعد الإغتسال من الجماع وبعدالبول وهو شيئ لزج
(الدر المختار مع رد المحتار، طهارة، سعيد ١/١٦٥)

قال في العلائية خرج مني بعد البول وذكره منتشر لزمه الغسل قال في البحر ومحمله ان وجد الشهوة وفي الشامية أن عدم وجوب الغسل بخروجه بعد البول اتفاقا اذالم يكن ذكره منتشر الخ
(ردالمحتار 1|149,سعيد)


And Allah knows best

18 Jumadal Ula Akhar 1442/ 01 February 2021

Mufti Qamruzzaman

London, UK