Forum Menu - Click/Swipe to open
 

Fazail E Amaal.

You have contributed 0.0% of this topic

Thread Tools
Appreciate
Topic Appreciation
Seifeddine-M, abu mohammed, Taalibah
3 guests appreciate this topic.
Rank Image
Maria al-Qibtiyya's avatar
Unspecified
620
Sister
202
Maria al-Qibtiyya's avatar
#31 [Permalink] Posted on 3rd May 2014 16:06
Understood. Jazakumullahu khairan for the info.
report post quote code quick quote reply
No post ratings
back to top
Rank Image
Maria al-Qibtiyya's avatar
Unspecified
620
Sister
202
Maria al-Qibtiyya's avatar
#32 [Permalink] Posted on 22nd May 2014 08:42
abu mohammed wrote:
View original post


So, there's no doubt that there're fabricated Ahadith in Fadhail e Amaal?
why do some scholars say that there's nothing wrong in taking such statements as Ahadith?
Those who don't know which ahadith are fabricated & which are not in Fadhail e Amaal, wouldn't it be sin if they read it, something which is made up and not actually the words of rasulullah sallalahu alaihi wasallam?
report post quote code quick quote reply
No post ratings
back to top
Rank Image
samah's avatar
Offline
USA
368
Brother
629
samah's avatar
#33 [Permalink] Posted on 22nd May 2014 09:00
Maria al-Qibtiyya wrote:
So, there's no doubt that there're fabricated Ahadith in Fadhail e Amaal?[/quote]

AskImam wrote:
A common comment made against Fazail-e-A'mal is that some of the narrations mentioned in it are weak and fabricated. This comment is not totally correct, as there are no fabricated narrations in this book. There are dha'eef (weak) narrations in Fazail-e-A'mal. However, it is important to point out that the word dha'eef, literally translated as 'weak', is a terminology and should not be understood in its general sense. Its application is based on the rules explained in the sciences of hadith. Moreover, weak narrations are not acceptable only in regards to aqeedah and the rulings of Islamic jurisprudence. Majority of the scholars have accepted weak narrations as far as virtues of good deeds are concerned. Even Imam Bukhari (Rahimahullah) has brought weak narrations in his book, Al Adabul Mufrad, which shows that he also accepts weak narrations in regards to virtues of good deeds.
[source]


[quote=Mufti Husain on sunniforum]Some Ulama are of the view that none of the ahadith in there are mawdu'.
They would therefore interpret someone saying that it does contain ahadith that are fabricated, as meaning that while they are fabricated according to that person, they are simply weak according to there Ulama.

You will find fabricated or extremly weak ahadith in nearly every hadith book. It isn't something peculiar to Fadhail A'mal.
Yes, due to this book being so famous, it is in the limelight more than others.

Hadhrat Shaykh did not mention ahadith that he knew to be fabricated.
They are either ahadith which the muhaddithin differed upon, with Hadhrat Shaykh adopted the view of those who found them to be acceptable,
or the Hadith books containing their chains where not published, thus Hadhrat Shaykh was unable to verify their authenticity himself and had to rely on other senior Muhaddithin who mentioned these narrations in their books without objecting to them.
[source]


This thread (archived version) may also be beneficial.
report post quote code quick quote reply
+3 -0Like x 3
back to top
Rank Image
Offline
Unspecified
1,203
Brother
119
#34 [Permalink] Posted on 22nd May 2014 17:03
The criticism against Fazail E Amail is baseless by some of these hardcore Salafis considering there are many books of Islam out there which, contain weak narrations and stories taken by other scholars and sources. Whether you choose to accept some of the interpreations from some the weak narrations is down to individual opinion.

Personally, I'm more comfortable and secure taking from authentic narrations considering there are plenty of them out there even if it's regarding fahdail topics.
report post quote code quick quote reply
No post ratings
back to top
Rank Image
Muadh_Khan's avatar
Offline
UK
11,537
Brother
107
Muadh_Khan's avatar
#35 [Permalink] Posted on 22nd May 2014 17:14

Maria al-Qibtiyya wrote:
View original post

Sister,

  1. There are weak/(possibly) fabricated Ahadeeth in Sunan Ibn Majah (RA) and other books
  2. There are weak/(possibly) fabricated Ahadeeth in Al-Adab Al-Mufrad of Imam Bukhari (RA)

So what will be done now? Its no big deal really

Jzk

report post quote code quick quote reply
+1 -0Like x 1
back to top
Rank Image
Maria al-Qibtiyya's avatar
Unspecified
620
Sister
202
Maria al-Qibtiyya's avatar
#36 [Permalink] Posted on 23rd May 2014 01:28
Jazakumullahu khairan.

samah wrote:
View original post


Hm. Difference of opinions.

Muadh_Khan wrote:
View original post


Got it.
report post quote code quick quote reply
No post ratings
back to top
Rank Image
Offline
Unspecified
20
Brother
32
#37 [Permalink] Posted on 23rd May 2014 04:00
report post quote code quick quote reply
+1 -0Like x 1
back to top
Rank Image
umm-e-abdullah's avatar
Offline
Unspecified
184
Sister
262
umm-e-abdullah's avatar
#38 [Permalink] Posted on 24th May 2014 04:38
Imam bukhari rahmat
hadeeth is considered to b one of the most authentic ahadeeth has written a book in the name of adab al mufrad that contains weak/fabricated ahadeeth as well... Now what? Will we stop giving references frm sahih bukhari just bcos hes written a book with a few collection of weak ahadeeth? scholars r in the opinion that weak hadith can b used in showing virtues (Fazail) but not be used in giving rulings (masail). Allah knows better.
report post quote code quick quote reply
No post ratings
back to top
Rank Image
Arfatzafar's avatar
Offline
India
1,269
Brother
1,581
Arfatzafar's avatar
#39 [Permalink] Posted on 24th May 2014 12:21
report post quote code quick quote reply
No post ratings
back to top
Rank Image
Jinn's avatar
Unspecified
2,891
Brother
277
Jinn's avatar
#40 [Permalink] Posted on 25th May 2014 12:16
Not sure if this has been mentioned :


Faizail-e-Amaal Aur Etarazaat ka Ilmi Jaezah

by Maulana Ilyas Ghumman


ia601709.us.archive.org/32/items/FazailEAmaalParAiteraazaatKaIlmiJayeza./Fazail%20e%20Amaal%20par%20Aiteraazaat%20ka%20Ilmi%20Jayeza.pdf
report post quote code quick quote reply
No post ratings
back to top