Shaykh Obsession

Brother,

This poster has no point. It’s a game being played by someone with an Agenda and we both know it...

Unfortunately we have brothers (and sisters) who crave attention or have some mental health issues which makes them go from forum to forum and raise the exact same issues and stir up trouble.

1. There is no doubt that there are issues with Tassawuff.
2. There is no doubt that there are issues with Darul-ulooms.
3. There is no doubt that there are issues with Tableeghi Jamaat.

But we don’t need attention craving folks to jump up and down and go from forum to forum discussing these matters without raising any specifics but merely ranting.

This brother (or sister) is merely ranting, he (or she) hasn’t constructed an argument, hasn’t raised any well constructed arguments, hasn’t defined a problem and hasn’t offered a solution. Shaykh (Maulana) Esa Mansuri (HA)’s article is just an afterthought (a bolt-on) when he (or she) is cornered and doesn’t know to turn left or right .

People have read a problem in this thread without the poster actually saying anything specific (just ranting) and it’s important for people to see that reading from beginning to end.

This is the ugly side of Internet and anonymity i.e. anyone can merely rant resulting in a 3 page fruitless exchange and time wasting.  This is precisely what happens on a daily basis on SF i.e. one person trolls and comes up with a half-baked ridiculous (rant) and others jump in and try to answer a rant with equally incoherent responses and then you have pages upon pages of nonsense until the thread is closed.

Constructive discussions and exchanges are of course welcome but attention craving individuals should be sent to their mother with one of these...

You can have a constructive forum where fruitful exchanges occur OR you can have 5 pages of non-nense!

Asslamo Allaikum,

Shaykh Mohammad Daniels (HA) of Cordoba Academy has been close to the Ulamah & Mashaykh of Tableegh (Nizamuddin Markaz) for almost 20 years and this is what he sent yesterday in Arabic which best describes Tableeghi Jamaat & its methodolody.

 حصّن نفسك وذكّر غيرك ​

Improve yourself and remind others!