THE DECEPTION OF THE MORON ‘MUFTIS’ OF THE MUFTISAYS INTERNET FORUM

Khala,

Nobody is either asking for a dissection of Fatwa nor expecting it so no discussion on this issue is necessary. 

You however admit that there is nothing (historically evident) from Deobandi Ulama about hurling abuses at other (Non-Deobandees) let alone fellow Deobandi Ulama. You also clearly see that there is an “aspect of disrespect” involved.

Nobody is asking for you to explain, dissect, understand, explain the nature of these statements. In fact in due deference honour and reverence to the noble Shaykh (HA) I have not dissected or condemned his action (either).

What we are saying to you is that sort of language is NOT FIT to be displayed when used for other Ulama.

What are his reason for using such language (we have not guessed or judged) but if you were to remove the name and merely send the Fatwaas (about leading Deobandi Ulama) to Darul-Iftaas around the world you will find that they will NOT approve this sort of language. That has also been done!

The simple point you are not understanding is that if disagreement with Ulama is not fit for public (laymen) consumption then abuse most certainly isn’t. Again nobody is expecting you to agree but at least to actually see someone’s clear point of view when you clearly agree that it is without precedence.

This isn't a technical discussion on a Fatwa but pure English language and comprehension matter. I am sure that you read and realise what is being said plainly and clearly.

Correct, that is his old site for which password etc has been lost!

I don't understand what you are saying at all. I apologise if I have hurt your feelings.

The issue is plain and clear when it comes to Majlis. You said that you are unable to judge the Academic nature so I reduced the argument to something you (and anyone else) can clearly spot and detect.

NOBODY in South Africa or UK takes the Majlis Fatwaas seriously (Academically) and feel free to check with any of the Ulama of your choice!

*Self Censor*Self Censor*Sel fCensor

She gets confused (amongst others) and its pretty clear from many of her posts based on unAcademic and unsound Fatwaas. Not her fault its the fault of others for not challenging responses which are not robust!

And this is why I tried my best for 2 days not to bring anything else in the discussion as you will pick the other strand of discussion up.

1. I unreservedly apologise for discussing matters which are not relevant
2. Sister can discuss it directly with me what I meant or didn't mean (in addition) to apology above.

I request you to draw line under this segment of the discussion.

Let’s get back to the crux and heart of the issue which is genuine and demonstrable abuse towards Ulama. Again nobody is asking you to explain it, nobody is asking you to defend it, nobody is asking you to justify or even condemn the simple request for 2 days is for you to merely understand that its there.

To the best of my knowledge and understanding Hazrat (HA) writes and answers everything himself...