From FazaiIEhajj :-
Once one of the mureeds of Shaikh Shibli; the great saint, came to visit him after having performed haj. The Shaikh asked him some questions. The mureed continues the story:
The Shaikh asked me: "Did you make a determined niyah for haj?"
I replied: "Yes I made a firm intention for performing haj."
Shaikh: "Together with having made a firm intention for haj; did you also have a firm niyah of forever giving up doing all those things you did since you were born that are opposed to the spirit of haj?"
I replied: "No, I did not."
Shaikh: "In that case you had no niyah for haj."
Then he said: "At the time of entering into the Ihraam; did you remove your clothing?"
I replied: "Yes, I did."
Shaikh: "At that time did you pledge to remove from you everthing save Allah?"
I replied: "No I did not."
Shaikh: "In that case you did not remove your clothing. Did you cleanse yourself by means of ghusl and wudhu?"
I replied: "Yes I did clean myself in that manner."
Shaikh: "At that time did you also become cleansed from all evil and faults?"
I replied: "No, that I cannot say."
Shaikh: "In that case you did not cleanse yourself. Did you recite labbaik?"
I replied: "Yes, I did recite lab'baik."
Shaikh: "Did you at that time hear the answers of lab'baik from Allah?"
I replied: "No, I received no reply."
Shaikh: "In that case what kind of Lab'baik did you recite? Did you enter the holy Haram?" (i.e. the area around Mecca.)
I replied: "Yes, I did."
Shaikh: "Did you at that time pledge to leave aside every Haraam (prohibited) act forever?"
I replied: "No, I did not."
Shaikh: Then you did not enter the area of the Haram Sharief at all. Did you visit Mecca?"
I replied: "Yes, I did."
Shaikh: "When you did, did you also see the Hereafter?"
I replied: "No, I did not see anything."
Shaikh: "Then you did not visit Mecca. Did you enter the Holy Mosque?"
I replied: "Yes, I did."
Shaikh: "Did you then, on entering feel the nearness of Allah?"
I replied: "No, I did not."
Shaikh: "Then you never actually entered the Masjid. Were you present at the Ka'bah?"
I replied: "Yes, I was."
Shaikh: "Did you then see that entity; due to which the Ka'bah is visited?"
I replied: "No, I saw nothing."
Shaikh: "Then you never saw the Ka'bah. Did you perform ramal at the time of tawaaf around the Ka'bah?" (Ramal signifies a running motion.)
I replied: "Yes."
Shaikh: "Did you at that time flee from this world in such a manner that you felt you were completely out of this world?"
I replied: "No."
Shaikh: "In that case you did not perform ramal. Did you place your hands on the black stone and kiss it?"
I replied: "Yes, I did."
The Shaikh then became very pale and greatly frightened, so much so that a shriek passed from him and he said; "Woe unto you: Rasulullah has said: `Whoever places his hands on the black stone, is like him who actually shook hands with Allah; and whoever shakes the hand of Allah shall in every way remain safe from all things'. Did you then feel anything about that security?"
I replied: "No, I did not."
Shaikh: "Then you did not touch the black stone. Did you perform two rak'ahs at the Maqaam-e-Ibrahim?"
I replied: "Yes, I did."
Shaikh: "You were at that particular time placed on a high rank by Allah; did you carry out what is due for that high rank; for which you stood there?"
I replied: "No, I did nothing."
Shaikh: "In that case you did not perform salaah at the Maqaam-e-Ibrahim. Did you perform Sa'ee between Safaa and Marwa; and did you ascend the Safaa?"
I replied: "Yes."
Shaikh: "And what did you do there?"
I replied: "I recited takbeer, thrice; and prayed to Allah to accept my haj."
Shaikh: "Did the angels also recite the takbeer with you, and did you have any knowledge of the significance of your own takbeers?"
I replied: "No."
Shaikh: "Then you actually did not recite the takbeer. Did you descend from Safa?"
I replied: "Yes."
Shaikh: "When you descended; did you feel all evil and every weakness departing from you, and inner cleanliness entering yourself?"
I replied: "No."
Shaikh: "Then you never ascended Safa nor descended from it. Did you run between Safa and Marwa?"
I replied: "Yes."
Shaikh: "At that time of running, did you feel yourself running away from everything else; besides Allah; and reaching Him?" (Referring to the Qur'aanic verse; Surah Shu'ra;
Translation: `And I fled from you when I feared You', and Allah in another place also says:
Translation: `And flee towards Allah'.)
I replied: "No."
Shaikh: "Then you never ran. Did you ascend Marwa?"
I replied: "No."
Shaikh: "In that case you never reached Muzdalifah. Did you perform Qurbani at Mina?"
I replied: "Yes."
Shaikh: "Did you then sacrifice your own self?"
I replied: "No."
Shaikh: "Then you performed no Qurbani. Did you perform Rami?" (Pelting the Shaytaan).
I replied: "Yes."
Shaikh: "With every stone that you threw, did you feel yourself shaking off you every form of ignorance and feel your knowledge increasing?"
I replied: "No." Shaikh: "Then you did not actually perform Rami. Did you perform the Tawaaf-uz-Ziyaarah?"
I replied: "Yes."
Shaikh: "Did you experience any spiritual enlightenment at that time, and from Allah did honour and respect descend upon you? for Rasulullah [sallallaahu alayhi wasallam] said: `One who performs haj, or one who performs umrah is Allah's guest; and when a visitor visits someone it is only correct that he should be honoured'."
I replied: "No, I experienced nothing."
Shaikh: "Then you never actually performed Tawaaf-uz-Ziyaarah. Did you then release yourself from ihraam?"
I replied: "Yes."
Shaikh: "Did you at that time promise to adhere to strictly Halaal earnings at all times?"
I replied: "No." Shaikh: "In that case you did not become Halaal (released from ihraam). Did you perform the farewell tawaaf?"
I replied: "Yes."
Shaikh: "Did you then say a complete farewell to your whole self, your desires and passions?"
I replied: "No."
Shaikh: "Then you did not perform Tawaaful Widaa. Go back and perform haj again; and perform it in the manner which I have described to you."
I have related this lengthy conversation from fazaiIEhajj to illustrate what type of Hajj the saintly ones do perform. May Allah Ta'ala in His infinite grace and mercy grant us all that type of hajj.