Abdur Rahman ibn Awf wrote:
View original post
I sincerely apologize and seek forgiveness from akbar703. Please forgive me for the sake of Allah Ta'ala.
Now to the topic at hand!
By Allah! There will be a lot of "I,I, I" below and it is not my intention to boast but just to state the facts:
Allah! save me from arrogance, Ameen.
- All my close relatives live in India and not in Pakistan
- I read 7-8 Indian Newspapers, publications and watch dozens of YouTube channels regularly
- Defense, Intelligence and Weapons has been my hobby and areas of personal research for the past 20+ Years
- I am relatively fluent in multiple languages (speaking, reading and writing)
- I have access to Senior Ulama and Darul-ulooms in both Pakistan and India
- I do have access to limited civil, military and intelligence information from Pakistan
- I participate in defense and intelligence based forums in topics related to both India and Pakistan
- I participate in defense and intelligence reddit in topics related to both India and Pakistan
Before Maulana Hasan Tai Saheb (RA) passed away in UK, he gifted his library and writings of his Hadhrat Maulana Syed Hussain Ahmed Madani (RA) to me and I read his rationale for opposition of Pakistan again and again and again.
I was very close in my youth to Hazrat Maulana Saleem Bahauddin Saheb (RA) who physically grew up in the house of Maulana Ashraf Ali Thanwi (RA) and often asking him about the dispute between Ulama.
I heard a lot from him about Maulana Ashraf Ali Thanwi (RA) directly.
I also have access to many smart and sincere people who specialize in India/Pakistan issues whom you see on podcasts, TV channels etc and I discuss matters which them all the time.
Despite all this, I am susceptible to error and open to discussion and I do not have any inherent love for India or Pakistan, they are both just lands where people live. These are political matters and anyone can be right or wrong but there is no room for nonsense and ridiculous Bakwaas.
I just have FOUR THINGS to say to you.
- You are in India so be loyal to India and opposed to Pakistan as Islam and pragmatism demands this of you.
- You are in India so protect yourself, your family and loved ones.
- Hindu can NEVER be loyal to a Muslim or Islam.
- There is nothing Muslims of India can do apart from maybe openly abandoning Islam and publicly prostrating to idols and giving Muslim women to Hindus to appease them.
Take it or leave it.
As far as India/Pakistan issue is concerned then Ulama did Political Ijtehaad and anyone has the right to challenge someone on Politics! Just because someone is an expert in Shaeeh Bukhari, does not make them an expert on Politics!
