mkdon101 wrote:
View original post
Simple answer is:
Saudi Ulama themselves have said that the sightings are not valid for the UK because of our geographical position.
However, these madkhalis and salafis don't follow this rule at all, they follow the TV.
Malaysia, how can we accept a ruling from a country from the other corner of the world?
The rules state that the moon must be sighted! Here, we have more of the sun than the moon at this time of the year, here the moon has to be above the horizon after Maghrib for it to be counted and SEEN, and even if it is above the horizon, otherwise if the moon sets before the sun or almost at the same time, then we've moved into another day of the same month, not the new month.
Try to use apps and see where the moon is in real time, then follow ita track to see if we will be able to sight it or not, but remember, these apps are just guides and cannot be used to fulfillt he Sunnah of a sighting without sighting it.