Wilfuly doing Biddah

Multiple people have said the same thing but you don’t seem to have the capacity to grasp it OR you are a troll and needs to be banned!

Anyone who has spent 15 minutes with Tableeghi Jamaat will grasp this instantly. The work on Tableeghi Jamaat is based on Mushwara and working under the guidance of Ulama and Mashaykh; it isn’t based on random Ijtehaad by individuals (don’t know where you get this idea from).

Before sending a Jamaat a thorough Karguzari is heard of the area/Masjid so the Jamaat (when picked by the Markaz) is aware of the circumstances and the Jamaat is picked to deal with the situation.

IF a Jamaat encounters an uncertain situation then Mushwara is done and again there is no such thing as individual Ijtehaad (dynamic or static).

So basically your 7 pages are full of RANT because if you CLAIM to be with Tableeghi Jamaat and have such CARE for the Ummah you CANNOT exercise your (dynamic Ijtehaad) whatever that is because if PROCEED with Jamaat (Insha’Allah) you will be subject to guidance of Markaz (Scholars, Mashaykh and old workers) and then by your Ameer.

If by (unfortunate circumstances) you find yourself to be the Ameer then you will still be subject to Mushwara and there are no “Hitler tactics” involved.

And we Thank Allah (SWT) for that because guidance is in obeying the commands of Allah (SWT) and following the Sunnah and not your "dynamic Ijtehaad".

salaam

but where will this "dynamic ijtihad" begin and where will it end? which one is acceptable and which do we reject?

1. ijtihad not from an established ruling, but from a minor ruling from within ones own madhab?

2. ijtihad not from ones own madhab, but from within any of the other madhabs?

3. ijtihad not from any madhab, but from within the quran and the hadith?

4. ijtihad not from the quran and hadith, but from bidah and shirk?

which one of these is the OP advocating?

salaam

what was the point of posting this if you do not disclose his name? if you disclose his name then others can try to understand your approach by comparing it to that of this person.

what is so secret about his name that you cannot post it?