

Do you always answer a question with a question? My 2 questions are written in very clear English and don't put words in my mouth and ask me to explain someone else's post.
By the way I have gone in Jamaat and also dealt with Bidatees, Salafees, Jamaat-e-Islami and Gair-Muqallids during my Chilli numerous times...


ok...
So in addition to being a dynamic Mujtahid you also get Ilhaam from Allah (SWT) to know what I agree or disagree with? Here are the simple questions to you:

As a youngster I invited Shaykh (Maulana) Saleem Bahauddin (HA) [Khaleefa of Shaykh (Maulana) Abrarul-Haq Hardoi (RA)] to my house in America. When Hazrat (HA) arrrived it was time for Ghusht so I explained the situation so he also wanted to go on Ghusht and we proceeded to the Masjid.
In Mushwara it was decided that Hazrat (HA) will remain in Dhik'r while we went out for Ghasht.
We got delayed while talking and missed the 1st Rakaat, then I gave the Bayan.
On the way back in the car Hazrat (HA) enquired, "I saw you completing the Salah at the end what happened"?
I said, "Well I was giving Dawat to someone so wanted to finish the talk and make Tashkeel and thought that I can join in Maghrib later?"
Hazrat (HA) just said, "If we miss our Takbeer-e-Oola ourselves which Deen are we inviting others to"?


If 2 is the answer which Ulama have authorised your actions?


Maulana Ahmed Raza Khan Barelwee was very close to my family so I have seen much more bId'ah up close and personal so you don't need to worry about what I have seen or not seen.
The questions for you are these two:
If 2 is the answer which Ulama have authorised your actions?



This cannot be undone and I am sure it will be greatly appreciated.
Please wait...