Assalamu alaykum
Maudhoo is the technical term for fabricated hadeeth.
For gair muqallideen all non-saheeh ahadith are fabricated.
Which one are you quoting.
Assalamu alaikum,
Quoting a fabricated Hadith, though an offence, is not equivalent to fabricating a Hadith. The Shaykh in question may be relying on some of his elders who may have recorded or narrated the hadith without its source. Hence, on the authority of his teachers may be narrating aHadith which may be fabricated.
The appropriate thing in such a situation would be to politey approach the shaykh and put one's concerns regarding the strength of the narration. For eg: Say to the shaykh 'Some people have cast doubts in me regarding the narration ............ I'm extremely perturbed and would like you to help me in alleviating the doubts.' One most not entertain any doubts regarding his shaykh until things are sorted out.
Caution: No sane Muslim who has fear of Allah and follows the sunnah would fabricate a Hadith. Further, a shaykh or an alim is a human like you and me and can definitely err. The Pious Elders have written that it is not a sign of a Wali to not err, rather a Wali does not remain on error once he is cautioned. With sincere taubah the Wali of Allah reaches more greater heights in the closeness of Allah than before.
W-Salam Hazrat,
The issue of gradation of narrations has nothing to do with Taqleed or Ghair-Muqallids. There are hunderds of books by Ulama on this matter and he has asked a question which doesn't concern Ghair-Muqallids at all.
Here are Fatwaas of Deobandi Hanafi Alim about fabrications:
www.hadithanswers.com/hadith-regarding-the-ulama-in-jannah/
www.hadithanswers.com/the-scholars-of-this-ummat-like-the...
? And the seriousness of lying about the Prophet and ascribing things to him which he did not say is described in the following (authentic) Hadith:
This cannot be undone and I am sure it will be greatly appreciated.
Please wait...
