Salamualaikum,
Brother, we need to get out this 'murdah parasti' .... it doesn't make much difference what hazrat did or didn't do. He will answer. Or get rewarded for his own deeds and we for ours.
Amal se zindagi banti hai jannat bhi jahannum bhi......
Get on with ur four months.
As for those who say its a big loss for the ummah, I dnt think so. I dnt think hazrats demise will have any great effect on the ummah. Bigger personalities hve left the world bfore him doesn't matter. Thousnands of biographies r thre for reading.
Amal amal amal... what others did or do dowsnt matter in ur grave.
Waste of time.
A better option to spend time is n seerah and hayat us sahaba.[/quote]
I replied:
Black Turban wrote:
Brother, can you show me a SINGLE quote from Quran/Hadith/scholars that it is okay to remain Jaahil?
Read this Hadith followed by your Jaahil statement:
Abu Darda رضي الله عنه narrates: I heard Rasulullah 
saying: The death of an 'Aalim is such a calamity that it can neither be made up nor compensated for; and he was a star (of guidance and due to his death) his light is lost. The death of a whole tribe is less significant than the death of an 'Aalim. (Baihaqi)
Darb ul Ubaah: As for those who say its a big loss for the ummah, I dnt think so. I dnt think hazrats demise will have any great effect on the ummah. Bigger personalities hve left the world bfore him doesn't matter. Thousnands of biographies r thre for reading.
NOW COMPARE !!!
His reply:
[quote=Darb ul Ubaah]
Assalam alaikum,
If u insist on taking ahadith on face value id request u to translate this hadith plz and then fit it as u see fit.
من مات ولم يغزو ولم يحدث به نفسه مات علي شعبة من نفاق
You can take help of this ayat to better understand the above hadith.
ولو ارادوا الخروج لاعدوا له عدة ولكن كره اللع انبعاثهم فثبتهم وقيل اقعدوا مع القاعدين
جزاك الله خيرا
