Guest wrote:
ashrafiya . com wrote:
An individual inquired that if it was still inappropriate to keep a face book account.
Sayyidi wa sanadi Shaikh Mufti Mohammad Taqi Usmani (Allah preserve him) replied,
'Yes indeed one should not have an account on the facebook . It is against the Islamic honor to do so. The desecration they did for our master Prophet Muhammad (Allah bless him and give him peace) was despicable.
However, I do not say that it is impermissible (na-jaiz/haram) to do so.
Some people tell me there is an account under my name also. I do not approve of it. I tell them to delete it if possible. I have no connection with it.'
Medinah e munawwarah, Al-Taiba Suites, 11th January 2011[/quote]
[/quote]
Im sorry this just seems like a complete contradicitons, In the first part it says the below
[quote=ashrafiya . com]'Yes indeed one should not have an account on the facebook . It is against the Islamic honor to do so. The desecration they did for our master Prophet Muhammad (Allah bless him and give him peace) was despicable.
Sayyidi wa sanadi Shaikh Mufti Mohammad Taqi Usmani (Allah preserve him) replied,
'Yes indeed one should not have an account on the facebook . It is against the Islamic honor to do so. The desecration they did for our master Prophet Muhammad (Allah bless him and give him peace) was despicable.
However, I do not say that it is impermissible (na-jaiz/haram) to do so.
Some people tell me there is an account under my name also. I do not approve of it. I tell them to delete it if possible. I have no connection with it.'
Medinah e munawwarah, Al-Taiba Suites, 11th January 2011[/quote]
[/quote]
Im sorry this just seems like a complete contradicitons, In the first part it says the below
[quote=ashrafiya . com]'Yes indeed one should not have an account on the facebook . It is against the Islamic honor to do so. The desecration they did for our master Prophet Muhammad (Allah bless him and give him peace) was despicable.
So Mufti is admitting and confirming the desecration of our master Prophet Muhammad (Allah bless him and give him peace) was despicable.
So how can he then go on to say
[quote=ashrafiya . com]However, I do not say that it is impermissible (na-jaiz/haram) to do so.
It just seems like a complete disregard for the first half of his statement. Its obvious he doesnt know what was said and done in this matter and how serious it was. Hence why he seems so "laid back" about it.
In some way you can even say that hes saying, ......O well what can you do? Just keep using Fitnah book. Its no biggy
Even a country like Pakistan blocked Facebook for 2 days in protest.
