bint e aisha wrote:
View original post
Nice to know. How about MTJ's repeats
You have contributed 0.0% of this topic
Many of the graduates of Darul-ulooms are Muqallids whom we classify as "Ulama". Their level of Taqleed is not much different to laymen.
Those who excel this category and actually teach and are Hafidh of their Madhab (important distinction) are also Muqallids but their Taqleed differs.
Carefully read the following in English and Urdu
www.central-mosque.com/index.php/taqleed/the-legal-status...
Pages 46 on wards
ia800309.us.archive.org/12/items/TaqleedKiShariHaisiyatBy...
Page 85 onwards.
P.S: Being Muqallid an honour for us and not a problem as the Madkhalees think.
The reason this does not apply to you as a lay person in your context is because the (other) Muqallid (even if she is a graduate of a Madrasah) is narrating the Hadeeth on the authority of Hazrat Shaykhul-Hadeeth Maulana Zakariyya Kandhalwi (RA) exactly and precisely. The weak and doubtful Ahadeeth in Fazail-e-Aamaal are worded in a specific manner.
In the case of incident quoted by the brother, the person narrated a Hadeeth from memory and the exact words of the Muhadith could not be narrated. For example a person can say “Nabi (Sallallaho Alaihe Wassallam) said…”
This is not how a Muhadith narrates a weak Hadeeth, read Fazail-e-Namaaz and the Hadeeth about fifteen punishments and notice the Urdu wordings very carefully and see how Hazrat Shaykhul-Hadeeth Maulana Zakariyya Kandhalwi (RA) has worded it.
The Urdu words of Hazrat Shaykhul-Hadeeth Maulana Zakariyya Kandhalwi (RA) are very precise, the English translation is NOT!
The Arabic is even more clear.
If you would have said that I “heard it” the situation would have been different. In your case the Muqallid is reading the precise (cautious) words of a Muhadith where he has doubts and he (RA) does express where he has doubts in Urdu clearly and unambiguously.
Anyone with basic grasp of Urdu language can tell the difference while reading Fazail-e-Amaal, I ask everyone to just read Fazail-e-Namaaz to grasp the issue on the most controversial parts of Fazail-e-Amaal.
P.S: 100% disagree with Hazrat Mufti Saheb (HA), Salaf NEVER gave permission to laymen (Muqallids) to go around advising people on Hadeeth.
Maulana Tariq Jameel (HA)'s bayans for the past 30+ years have been filled with weak, extremely weak and fabricated narrations. The Deobandees usually DO NOT have a problem with this issue which is the most important problem with Maulana Tariq Jameel (HA).
Deobandees think that Maulana Tariq Jameel (HA) praising Maulana Maududi (RA) or Maulana Ahmed Raza Khan Barelwee (RA) or Dr Farhat Hashmi OR speaking in front a university audience with women are BIGGER ISSUES then these narrations, tells you all you need to know about Deobandi priorities
Even the words (his translation) is clear but as I am saying that they are not grasping it. There is a specific way he translates it which makes the doubt apparent. Tableeghees are neither taught this nor are interested.
The reason you are writing all of this is because Masha’Allah you have actually exerted the time and effort to understand these issues, a normal Deobandi woman would NEVER write this stuff in a million years because she will perform Hazrat Worship and be content with it. The Hazrats who give Bayans will treat most women like IDIOTS and never discuss these topics. The level of discourse amongst (most) women Bayans and Bayans amongst men is of different level (unfortunately).
YouTube has levelled the playing field and you are listening to issues TODAY which never in a million years you will listen in a women Bayan.
Instead of teaching women the subtleties of attending Moques and HOW and WHY, it’s easier to just say it is HARAM for you to attend the Mosque because you are too STUPID to grasp the technicalities of the points in a Bayan, same for haircuts etc.
That is why many well grounded, professional and Islamically proficient and knowledgeable Sisters are not Deobandees! Because they are spoken to the level of a child and treated like a child. This is in the west
This cannot be undone and I am sure it will be greatly appreciated.
Please wait...
