View original post
You have a habit of asking questions which are never claimed. You continue to ignore responses and keep asking the same things over and over again because you “think” that it is the point of view of the person.
Instead of “thinking” about my point of view, READ and THEN ask me about my point of view. I am going to repeat myself and make a few point and then I will get to your questions.
Statement 1: I am not against science and education. But first comes spirituality and aqeedah.
Clarify where I have claimed anything other than that?
Statement 2: And I say the problem is spiritual and the wise ones say Nay! But you are a fool...
I have claimed that the problem is not just spiritual
Statement 3: However, I strongly believe that once the spiritual problem is solved, other problems will be sorted out automatically.
Where did you get this from? Can you provide evidence from the Qur’aan and Sunnah? Where does it say that?
Statement 4: For me Makkah means any place where the system of Islam is not implemented and where you can't give dawah for khilafah without trouble. Means that when you will give dawah to those who are in authority to change the current political, socio-economic system then you will be ridiculed, tortured, bigoted the same way Prophet Muhammad SAWS and his companions ra were being tortured back in Makkah. Maulana Abdul Aziz and his students in Lal Masjid are a prime example for that.
Maulana Abdul Aziz is anextremist Takfeeri TTP supporter and I do not subscribe to the ideology of planting bombs in Mosques and killing Muslims, you may do and that’s up to you. I do not advocate making Takfeer and killing Muslims.
Statement 5: Are secular countries, countries of Muslim Ummah. Do they protect Muslim Ummah?
Who has claimed this?
Statement 6: Are these countries Islamic or Muslim?
Any country which borders an Islamic country is Darul-Islam and a ruler which has “the ability” to implement Islam is a Muslim…whether he does so or not is a different matter. The ability to implement Shariah is the point and not the actual implementation. The person is a grave sinner for not trying.
Statement 7: If secular countries are not caretakers of this ummah and are not Islamic or represent the political-socio-economic side of Islam and if you agree to this then show me one example where Prophet Muhammad SAWS instructed his Sahaba RA while in Makkah to gain worldly skills which will later on help build khiafah in Madina.
Are you claiming that Allah Ta’ala had FORETOLD THEM that you will be establishing Khilafah in Madina and they deliberately neglected the future. I am Sorry but you are severally mistaken!They acted according to Wahi, they carried on with their lives and REACTED to the circumstances WHILE being fully engaged in matters of Dunya (family, work,business dealings etc). Today, my model is Qur’aan and Sunnah and it tells me:
Statement 8: If we remain silent and don't give dawah of khilafah openly
There is no “Dawah” to Khilafah,there is “Dawah to Islam” and entirety of Islam...There is no such as Dawah towards "Khilafah", it is component of Islam
Statement 9: My question remains unanswered. Give one example where Prophet Muhammad SAWS instructed his companions RA in Makkah to gain worldly skills so that these can be used to build Khilafah state in Madinah or any where else. What was his main focus in that area?
To survive oppression and act on the Wahi of Allah Ta’ala as it was revealed. TODAY, the Deen is complete so we need to act on the Shariah as it is given to us. Makkah was a half-way point and revelation was still occurring (as I have rightly pointed out by multiple verses which you have ignored.
Why don’t you also advocate drinking since it was permissible in Makkah?
- My ideal is not Mao or bomb planting Takfeerees, my ideal is Muhammad (Sallallaho Alaihe Wassallam) of Madina
- Makkah was a transitional phase in Islamic history and revelation was still being received. TODAY, the revelation is complete and I will look at the Shariah holistically and not pick and chose from incomplete revelation because Allah Ta'ala tells me:
Loading Qur'aan Verse
Give your evidence from fully completed Islam and not XYZ and half revealed verses and your imagination.
Khilafah is a RESULT which Allah Ta'ala will bestow upon Muslims by following the Deen. You CANNOT establish it! You can (and should) the political and governance system of Islam but Allah Ta'ala will BLESS us with Khilafah by us shunning sins and follow Sunnah (including abandoning usury etc).
Loading Qur'aan Verse
By giving Dawah, do you mean that you are highlighting the socio-political system of Islam and making people aware? I can see that but it is ridicolous to claim that you are giving "Dawah" towards Khilafah! Dawah is towards Allah Ta'ala and Islam.
Loading Qur'aan Verse