8
Apr
2016

A (suggestive) Plan of Action for the Deobandees

8th April 2016

In the Name of Allah, the Most Gracious, the Most Merciful.

As-salāmu ‘alaykum wa-rahmatullāhi wa-barakātuh

The recent attacks in the Media against the Deobandees are not hidden from anyone and need no further publicising. I wish to propose a suggestive plan of action, it is only my humble opinion and since I am (most certainly) nobody there is no compulsion on anyone to take it.

This is simply my Mushwara as being part of the Ummah of Nabi (Sallallaho Alaihe Wassallam).

IMMEDIATE & MANDATORY ACTION:

All Muslims should IMMEDIATELY STOP sending links of news articles via WhatsApp and STOP posting links on twitter, Facebook, social media etc. Distribution of this material helps those who wish to malign us. As more of these articles are spread with the links, the clicks go above, news moves up the popularity cycle and it forces news agencies to spend more time and resources and come up with more dirt.

This is the best advice which came from Mufti Amjad Mohammed (HA), Masha’Allah.

If you do need to tell people about these, copy/paste the content and just mention that such and such media organisation published it today (or whenever).

STOP sending half-baked WhatsApp messages and social media posts just because it was written by someone you like, it serves no purpose and if publicly circulated makes us look like fools.

Positive Mind-set:

It is not an achievement to solve a problem! The real success is in turning an apparently losing position into one of strength. There are those amongst us who believe in conspiracy theories so instead of sensing an opportunity they spend the time:

  1. Looking for who fed the information to the Media
  2. Convincing others that dealing with the Media is futile because they will twist your views etc
  3. Convincing others these attacks are part of some sort of well-orchestrated Qadiyani/Zionist alliance so all efforts are futile

There may be some element of truth in these theories but these sort of people sap the energy of others through negativity and should be kept away from these issues.

Yesterday, Shaykh (Maulana) Yunus Dudhwala (HA) appeared on BBC Asian Network and he was able to successfully articulate the position of Islam with regards to the Qadiyanees during Live coverage.

Allah (SWT) has given us a superb opportunity to convey Islam to 60 million British people so view this as a golden opportunity and take it both hands.

Aggression vs Professionalism:

Many of our Brothers and Sisters want to go to war with the Media and respond in highly aggressive manner. It is counterproductive and feeds into (their narrative). Respond in a restrained but firm and professional manner.

This is NOT a clash of civilisation but a clash of political ideologies and mind-set, don’t turn it into a battle ground.

Keep hot-headed, aggressive people away from these debates.

Conspiracy vs Facts:

Many of our Brothers and Sisters have a head full of conspiracies and they view everything with coloured glasses. It is regrettable and unfortunate that some of the Ulama are also beginning to forward conspiracy theories on WhatsApp and social media.  

They are entitled to their opinion but keep them away from these discussions, confine them to forums and let them argue with each other.

We have enough facts to make our case, Insha’Allah. Here are some recommendations and these stages are not rigid and can be adjusted (as necessary).

Don't criticise your own people!

No need to publicly put down your own people. Those who put their necks out should be appreciated and if they make mistakes they should be advised privately.

Even the best should consult Ulama:

EVEN the best people need to consult Ulama on specific positions and this is vital.

STAGE 1 (Speak to the British Nation!):

Deobandees specialise in preaching to the converted and it’s about this approach is radically altered. Those who agree with you, know where you stand so what’s the point of speaking in Urdu, Asian, Islamic clichés etc?

We need to learn to address those who don’t understand it so drop the clichés and lingo. Address people in simple words, tone and language that they understand, our target should be 60 million British people or in fact the whole world.

I have YET to find a single simple article about Qadiyanees or a video which explains the problem, here is a start:

STAGE 2 (Who/What is a Deobandi?):

The first response to the British public should be convey that being a “Deobandi” is a nuanced position. It isn’t a monolithic sect with a standard of beliefs and dogma. Media wants people to see Doebandees as a “cult” and our job should be to show that it isn’t as simple as that.

Do all graduates of Oxford hold the same set of views? Make the British public understand this and as simply as possible.

Wifaqul Ulama has taken the lead and constructed an excellent treatise on this issue...

STAGE 3 (Make it a British issue):

The focus in the Media is that some (foreign) radical preachers arrived in Britain and our (native and naïve) Muslims were misled. It is insulting to propose that someone like Masood Azhar arrived from Pakistan and radicalised Deobandees, such insinuations are from a colonial mind-set.

We have hundreds of Ulama and Institutions and it’s about we stand on our two feet. The issue of Ahmadees/Qadianees is a golden opportunity for us to respond. This is an agreed upon issue in Islam.

  1. Draft a statement, see example from Wifaqul Ulama but change it to fit your needs
  2. Ulama should lobby their teachers and heads of Darul-ulooms and make them endorse it
  3. Ulama and leaders should lobby Barelwees and others like (Dr) Haitham Al-Haddad, (Dr) Akram Nadwi and others to endorse it because you need to present this as a British position (and it is)

Again, this is an ideal opportunity for Muslims to develop links and strengthen ties. Remember that it needs to be Deobandi position and not a Deobandi or a Bury or Dewsbury or Leicester position...

STAGE 4 (Pick another British/Islamic issue):

Palestine is an issue with considerable support from mainstream British public. Make it an issue and present a united front.

If you skip this step, know that sooner or later Media will pick you up on Palestine and try to paint you as Anti-Semitic.

STAGE 5 (Introduce Deobandees to British Public):

It’s about time we go on a front foot and tell British public that we are not hidden, have no clandestine agenda and contribute very positively to this society.

I am working on a documentary so if you have any ideas, contact me and I will be happy to hear from you.

STAGE 6 (Appear on Media):

Issuing statements is good but we need to appear on the Media. The more you appear the more people get used to your views and it is likely that Media will invite you again.

NOT responding to Media requests is criminal, Deobandees have tried this for 40+ years and it has gotten us into this mess which we now find ourselves.

STAGE 7 (Back Talent!):

This is the cancer which is eating away at the heart of Deobandees. A person is backed because he is a Mureed, Gujrati, attends someone’s Majlis etc etc etc.

Learn to back talent and be prepared when talented people disagree with you (and they will!) We have plenty of money, resources, Intelligence and talent of our own in this Ummah, we just need to back the right people.

STAGE 8 (Involve Women!):

You can pretty much seal your fate but if you don’t involve women in any of your campaigns, nothing else needs to be said.

STAGE 9 (Use Social Media):

British Muslims are younger and highly tuned into social media frenzy, start using social media to your advantage…begin using hasthatgs like #DeobandiIslam etc and make it trend

Established media cannot compete with you on social media and you can take the battle to them (fairly easily) in an organised manner.

STAGE 10 (Learn response Tactics):

British Media is bound by code of practise so learn to use it. BBC aired a program, Deobandees all over the country should have gone to town in reporting this (as biased) and prevented Part 2 from airing. Massive number of reports would have put BBC on the back foot.

We should have officially come up against this program, clearly told masses on how to report and given a sample complaint.

Ulama and Mashaykh should have gone to town with publicly endorsing this approach.

You wouldn’t be sitting here reading this response if we had done the basics. :P

I bet that you have read this and said "this is common sense" and yes it is!

Jazakallau Khayran
 

posted by Muadh_Khan on 8th April 2016 - 6 comments

6 Comments

ahamed sharif wrote on 8 Apr 2016
I am surprised, this is about deoband and we are not consulting Mol Salman Hussaini Nadvi DB, Mol Khaleelurrahman Sajjad DB, Mol Taqi Uthmani DB and other senior deobandi ulema. India is also passing through the same.
Blogger's Reply:
Great Ulama but we have plenty of Ulama and very capable ones in UK. Jzk
 
Ryder wrote on 8 Apr 2016
Agree with most of what you said, however:

1. People have a habit of writing off all independant anaylsis that disagrees with the "official" narrative as a conspiracy. This is also a problem. Why should we always stick with the official narrative when we are all too aware of the half truths, twists and hypocrasy involved of the media and authorities?

2. Your "STAGE 2 (Who/What is a Deobandi?):" How? Which mainstream media will allow us to explain and express ourselves in the way we want?

3. Your "STAGE 5 (Introduce Deobandees to British Public):" again, how?

4. Your "STAGE 6 (Appear on Media):" Very bad idea except for a select few. THe number of people I would trust to be capable of appearing on media and not making a fool of us can probably be counted on one hand.

I wholeheartedly agree with the rest of what you've written.
Blogger's Reply:
You posted this message and then posted the same message a day later on the 09th of April when this was already activated the day before. I didn't comment because there is nothing in your message to comment upon.
 
Pleasejustshutup wrote on 9 Apr 2016
I read that we need to present the sublime message of Islam, what exactly is that message then? That slavery is legal, marrying 9 year old girls is ok because Deobandis are Hadith worshippers. How can you logically criticise paedophia? Sicko, why don't you stick to talking to creeps from Pakistan and getting every pervert married 4 times, while they dream about their slaves. Really, you're no different from ISIS, they've only put into practice the logical conclusions of the rubbish you guys spout. I'm no quilliam supporter, and I detest Majid nawab types, but thank Allah for him otherwise the Muslims who actually know what they're on about would have forever been silenced by you rubbish. For once in your pathetic lives, just shut up, and do nothing. Deobandis provide what is needed for the type of people it's aimed at. Carry on doing that, and don't talk about stuff you know nothing of, fools.
Blogger's Reply:
Nothing but incoherent rant!
 
Asaaghir wrote on 14 Apr 2016
Although, like Oxford, there are branches. You will most surely get branches in religion too, but when it comes to one branch, i.e. Deoband, then why so many differences, when in actual fact, they should ALL be on the same belief. Let me give you an example of firstly UK Deobandi's and then non UK Deobandi's

UK Deobandi's have 2 groups of Moon sighting, no sign of unity. No unity in the starting time of prayers causing conflict up and down the country, no sense of direction with regards to Halal and doubtful food, you have HMC on one side, then you have other Deobandi's who give Fatwa's on the contrary. Then there is the Deobandi issue of the MEGA Mosque. Deobandi Scholars who oppose celebrating Christmas and those right on top of em all wishing other a Merry Christmas lololol.

Non UK Deobandi's like Taliban (Afghan), Darul Ifta Nazimabad, Mufti Rasheed Ludhyanvi, Ml Masood Azhar and so on, all these Jihadi heros, Tablighi Jamaat Deobandi's who oppose Jihad galore :)

There's major flaws in this school of Deoband. I wouldn't say they are different branches, I would say there is no unity.

And to end on light humor, we have Mufti Abdur Raheem Limbada, an excellent scholar who is well versed in knowledge but must always remain politically correct as oppose to another scholar from accross the pond, Mufti A.S Desai! Need I say more ;)

So which Deobandi are we followers of in the UK?
Blogger's Reply:
Your understanding of issues is incorrect but it is answered in this video: www.youtube.com/watch?v=LoJVDGSrJKo
 
Abdi M wrote on 18 Apr 2016
Question

A brother has an idea which is to produce a TV Documentary on Deobandees in light of the media attack on Deobandees in the UK.

He says he needs to do something for the Ummah right now and has requested sisters to come forward who wish to speak on camera.

On his Twitter account he is moaning to Muftis that he can't get hold of any women for the documentary.

Surely a TV programme involving at least the voice and possibly the face of a ghayr mahram is impermissible or am I missing some Fiqh that the self-styled scholar has tapped in to?

Is this not case of using batil means to propagate Haq?á

Anyway he has requested Du'as for his forthcoming documentary.

We have forthwith provided the necessary evidential links of the said postings.

What is the Shar'i ruling regarding such a documentary?

http://www.muftisays.com/forums/27-sharing-portal/10916-documentary-on-deobandees.html

https://mobile.twitter.com/Muadh_Khan/status/719883152811012098

https://mobile.twitter.com/Muadh_Khan/status/719883529476251648

Answer:

Assalaamu alaykum

Not pemissible to make flims of animate objects.

We have to do the work of dawat and tabligh and make them muslim.

If people want to continue criticizing then we cannot stop them.

This is happening from the time of Nabi Sallallahu alayhi wasallam.

MUFTI A K HOOSEN
Blogger's Reply:
W-Salam, How do you know that I have tapped into a "self-styled Scholar"? Do you know which Scholars I have consulted? Genuine question...Jazakallahu Khayran
 
Abdi M wrote on 20 Apr 2016
The self-styled scholar is yourself as evidenced by your juggernaut attitude to others.

Please note that your modernist batil attitude has little Shar'i basis in resolving the issue at hand (see fatwa below).

Is it necessary for you to be contacting sister Fatima or whichever other unsuspecting ghayr mahram to appear on a TV programme. Really?

On his Twitter account he is moaning to Muftis that he can't get hold of any
women for the documentary.

Surely a TV programme involving at least the voice and possibly the face of a
ghayr mahram is impermissible or am I missing some Fiqh that the self-styled
scholar has tapped in to?



Question:
You may have heard of brother Mu'adh Khan from UK (aka Colonel). He has
connection with Deobandee Ulama and is mostly well regarded.

His latest idea or fad (call it what you will) is to do a TV Documentary on
Deobandees in light of the media attack on Deobandees in the UK.

He says he needs to do something for the Ummah right now and has requested
sisters to come forward who wish to speak on camera.

Is this not a case of using batil means to spread the Haq?

Answer:

Haamidan wa Musalliyan
Assalamu Alaikum wa Rahmatullahi wa Barakaatuh

This is completely against the teaching of Deoband. Appearing on the television screen and interviewing women is not at all in keeping with the high and lofty teachings of the elders of Deoband. The teachings of the elders of Deoband are in conformity to the Sunnah of Rasulullah (Sallallahu Alayhi Wasallam).

And Allah Ta'alaá(الله تعالى)áknows best.

Answered by:

Mufti Ebrahim Salejee

Blogger's Reply:
Love you too Brother although no idea What "unsuspecting ghayr mahram" means in English but if this makes you sleep well tonight so be it...Good Night and enjoy
 
Write a comment
(required) - not published nor available to blogger
Blogs Disclaimer: The views expressed in these blogs are those of the author(s). The blog is monitored with set guidelines. Inapproproate content should be reported on our forums for the attention of our moderators.