Q&A Home » Tafseer, Hadeeth, Du'aa

Urgent Hadith explanation

Last updated: 15th March 2007
Question ID: #4011
Short URL: http://qa.muftisays.com/?4011
Printer Friendly Version Email this page
Sarah
15th March 2007

 
Salaam.Please refer to the two hadiths below.Narrated Jabir bin 'Abdullah : A funeral procession passed in front of us and the Prophet stood up and we too stood up. We said, 'O Allah's Apostle! This is the funeral procession of a Jew." He said, "Whenever you see a funeral procession, you should stand up." Bukhari 2:23:398.................................................. .................................................. ....Narrated 'Abdur Rahman bin Abi Laila: Sahl bin Hunaif and Qais bin Sad were sitting in the city of Al-Qadisiya. A funeral procession passed in front of them and they stood up. They were told that funeral procession was of one of the inhabitants of the land i.e. of a non-believer, under the protection of Muslims. They said, "A funeral procession passed in front of the Prophet and he stood up. When he was told that it was the coffin of a Jew, he said, "Is it not a living being (soul)?" Bukhari 2:23:399The above two hadiths have been explained by a brother in this manner: "we learn the underlying cause (Asbaab-ul-Hadeeth اسباب الحديث) through authentic sources that Allaah’s Messenger Muhammad صلی الله عليه وسلم stood up so that the bier would not pass above the heads of the Muslims, as this is a form of humiliation to them. If this is the underlying reason (which in fact is) for his standing up, then the practice of standing up for a bier (Janaaza جنازه) will be restricted to the bier of a disbeliever.But i and all my other muslim brothers and sisters have always known that the Prophet (s) stood up because of what he said in the hadiths and basically to show respect to humanity.What is the correct explanation?jazakzwsalaam



Answer
Bismillah

Al-jawab billahi at-taufeeq (the answer with Allah's guidance)


According to Imam Abu Hanifa, Imam Safi'ee and Imam Malik (Rahmatullahi Alaihim), the Qiyam (standing up) for the Janazah (funeral) is abrogated. (Sharah Nawawi 'Ala Saheehil Muslim Vol.1 Pg.310)

Narrated Ubadah ibn as-Samit:

The Apostle of Allah (Sallallahu Alaihi Wasallam) used to stand up for a funeral until the corpse was placed in the grave. A learned Jew (once) passed him and said: This is how we do. The Prophet (Sallallahu Alaihi Wasallam) sat down and said: Sit down and act differently from them. (Abu Dawud, Book 20, Number 3170)

(See also: Tahawi Vol.1 Pg.235, Sunan Al Baihaqi Vol.4 Pg.20)

(Darse Tirmidhi Vol.3 Pg.320,321)



And Only Allah Ta'ala Knows Best.

Mufti
Answer last updated on:
23rd April 2008
Answered by:
Ulamaa ID 04
Website
Location: London