You have contributed 0.0% of this topic
At the outset, know that ALL asbab get their effect from Allah alone. No panadol/tylenol or aspirin will have any effect whatsoever unless Allah puts the effect in it.
It is the same for any ruqya, ta'weez or medicinal practice.
So for the question of why to use pepper, etc. Allahu A'lam. This is what the researcher of the field figure out. These things happen to generally have a positive outcome. So they do tajarubaat, and see what is the general correlation. I have no clue how they determine this.
All I can say is even if these actions are 100% positive correlation with cure, the cure is from Allah alone. So regardless of correlation, we will still assess whether the practice has shirk in it, or does it have tashabbuh with a procedure specific to another religion or qawm.
I can only mention greatly about Pakistan. Ulama of india can assess the custom and norm of india.
In Pakistan, the genuine ulama' do use some such treatments, however mostly they disassociate the practice from hinduistic norm by combining du'a and adhkar with them. No hindu would do an amal while glorifying Allah. So in this way they break the tashabbuh.
At the same time, there are still many phony peers in Pakistan who do these actions with wierd unknown incantations. All those are to be rejected. Just as you seek an honorable Mufti/Alim for your deeni islaah, search for an honorable deeni amil for medical/spiritual assistance.
So if an honorable Amil who you can see is muttabi' sunnah, prescribe such an action for you, rely on him and carry it out. However, if you see some glaring red flags yourself then just avoid.
Avoidance and sticking to masnun du'as is always better.
Indian demographic and norms with hindu customs will be assessed by a scholar who is in those areas. Just keep a general healthy aprehension for non masnun a'maals. Insha'Allah your avoidance, even from something Mubah will be rewardworthy.
Let me give you some free advice.
There is NOBODY alive today who can tell you that someone has done Magic on you, it is not possible. They speculate and sometimes the speculation may be accurate.
As Dr76 has rightly pointed out that over 99% of those who portray themselves as experts in this fields are fakes and charlatans. Even those who are not fakes or charlatans and try to treat patients with sincerity are not knowledgeable.
I know a brother who was an ex professional and now does Ruqya after retirement. He knows Shariah and he is very meticulous in his note taking, analysis and also understands the basics of psychology and psychiatry. When he was working, this person was at the top of his profession.
I am trying to impress upon you that he is not dumb or stupid.
He has hundreds of case studies of his patients and he is extremely thorough in his diagnosis and meticulous in his adherence to Sunnah and treatment. He is not need of money and neither has the need to scam people.
The first thing he tells patients is that the cure is from Allah and in the Sunnah. NOBODY has the knowledge of the unseen except Allah and NOBODY can give them definite answers. He will recommend certain treatments which he has learned from studying the Sunnah and from experience but cure is with Allah.
If Allah wishes, the patient will be cured.
If Allah wishes, the patient may not be cured.
Rely upon the Allah and know that this is a test, our job is to be servants of Allah and be patient.
In short, an honest, educated, qualified and professional (sincere) person will not make pie in the sky announcements. You can hear YouTube videos where some Ulama make bold claims that this will cure all sorts of cancers etc is just stupid. Unfortunately, due to lack of knowledge in the Ummah Muslims falls for these gimmicks.
The hardest thing in the world is to change yourself. The easiest thing is to BLAME someone else for your problems and Black Magic/Jinn is a convenient excuse.
I have said this before and I am saying it again! Even if someone is affected by Black Magic/Jinn they can still live a fairly balanced/normal life IF THEY WANT TO! It is a test from Allah and no different to living with any other sort of illness like diabetes, blood pressure etc.
You turn to Allah and you cope.
This cannot be undone and I am sure it will be greatly appreciated.