On the Topic:
www.muftisays.com/forums/75-books/8425-the-meccan-rebelli...
Quote:
There is direct testimony of Pakistan Army officer who was involved in this operation on the Internet but since this has never been unclassified, I am unable to provide official accounts. The only dispute is whether it was Parvaiz Musharraf who commanded it or not.
Off the Topic:
abu mohammed wrote:
View original post
Mufti Saheb is targetting me and no one else on the forum. Rest assured that I try to read everything directed at me and if there is something which needs clarification on my part, I respond. In case of personal attacks, I do respond to defend myself.
If its something which has already been answered (multiple times) I ignore it to not flood the system.
If it's a "rant" its their democratic privilege so let them...
ALIF wrote:
View original post
He has not mentioned it in his book because maybe:
- He never did it
- It is classified
Either way whether Musharraf was part of the operation or not it makes no difference to his (current) judgement.
You asked sometime ago about targetting of "Sufees" and I talked about their intense hatred and poison. Imagine a person engaged in "Islah" from the best of the elders and that is all they are focused on. After years of involvement, they cannot let go of their hatred and poison SO then we have to think that the system is not working.
I can (Astagfirullah) become apostate and then become Muslim again and these people will forgive me. BUT they will never forgive me for pointing out that "Hazrat worship" is destroying the Ummah. If I was to become Bay't to a "Hazrat" tomorrow and for the rest of my mortal life dissociate myself from the Dunya and remain in Tazkiyah, I will NEVER be forgiven (by them) and such is the poison of hate. A brother one told me that these "Sufees" react to criticism of their "Hazrat" with much more venom then they react to the criticism of Nabi (Sallallaho Alaihe Wassallam)
3 days ago, they did not even know much about Parvaz Musharraf's book until I told them that he admits handing people to CIA. 3 days later, they are questioning what is classified and what is unclassified based on my own post without reading anything.
- Pakistani Army was part of the operation to clear out the Terrorists from Haram
- Parvaiz Musharraf was part of the operation to clear out the Terrorists from Haram
2 separate matters and they could be mutually exclusive.
EVEN IF Musharraf was part of the operations, it makes no difference to his current legal predicament and no difference to potential crimes which he could be tried for.
Everyone on this forum (disagreeing with me) knows fully well that my point is that the punishment meted out to Parvaiz Musharraf for treason and violating Article 6 does not (legally) stack up and I fear that it will be overturned.
YET they put Taqwa aside and engage in attacks by twisting clear words deliberately because of their intense (personal) hatred.
And YET you think that Tasawuff (today) does not have a problem? Do you not witness this day in and day out? Is the behaviour of those who confess to be engaged in "Islah" not worrying?