ummi taalib wrote:
View original post
A young wise brother was talking to me a year or so ago.
We were discussing the disproportional Sufi response to others when their Mashaykh are discussed. Recently, we had the despicable incidents of images attributed to Nabi (Sallallaho Alaihe Wassallam) and the Sufi reaction was pretty much of life (as usual) they propagated turning to Allah (SWT), making more Dhik’r etc i.e. no concerete action.
Contrast this to Sufi action when their Mashaykh are discussed:
- You get hated
- You get slandered
- You get absued
- The Sufees will drop the discussion like a hot potato
- The Sufees will break relatioship with you
- The Sufees will break relationship with whatever format this discussion is taking place
The only logical explanation is that the Sufees have elevated their Mashakh to the rank of Nabi (Sallallaho Alaihe Wassallam) and the manner THEY SHOULD be reacting to the (perceived) insult of Nabi (Sallallaho Alaihe Wassallam) they do so to their Mashaykh.
Your advice to me was as follows:
- Incorrect beliefs are incorrect beliefs no matter WHO it is held by (relatives, friends, family etc)
This is totally 100% in line with Islam, no issues. Problem is that the minute you are shown categorical proof of your own Mashaykh going close to this line you turn away in the most ardent manner.
Problem is that you have no problems bashing Barelwees, Salafees, Qadiyanees, Aga Khanees etc with impunity but the minute you are shown your own Sufi Mashaykh holding the same beliefs or doing the same things you turn away in disgust.
Now I know that YOU ARE INTELLIGENT ENOUGH to clearly grasp what is written in simple English so you may try to deceive us by claiming “Old Auntie cannot understand English etc “ excuse but you cannot trick Allah (SWT) and deep down you know that you are clearly confronted with an example above and an example below which you CANNOT explain! Instead of saving your Aakhira you want to throw tantrums and once again leave the forum etc.
Point 2:
Dr Tahirul-Qadri on greeting/celebrating Christmas
Darul-uloom Bury on Christmas Greeting!
www.muftisays.com/blog/Muadh_Khan/3542_23-01-2014/darulul...
Playing the Victim card!
Once again you are confronted with a situation based on your own writing and once again you are paying the victim card
O look poor old Aunty is being bullied and harrased
And your Sufi comrades are out in full force with their dislikes because they CANNOT COUNTER THE FACTS!
Correct, rational Islamic behvaior
Nobody is expecting you or anyone else to start issuing Fatwaas on Ulama but what is expected from you is to (at least) say that I don’t agree with it but I cannot offer an explanation and I am in no position to offer an explanation or an answer and Ulama should be consulted on the matter.
INSTEAD YOU PLAY THE VICTIM CARD TO GAIN SYMPATHY BUT MOST IMPORTANTLY YOU DO IT TO DIVERT ATTENTION AWAY FROM THE SUBJECT AND YOU KNOW THAT VERY WELL!