You have contributed 10.0% of this topic
Maulana Yusuf Shabbir tweets about the controversy.
So the Imam from Makkah can sell the Ummah to the dogs but it is not permitted to question him? When did we become Catholics?
I don't necessarily agree with the man and not really paid attention to his “questioning” but WHERE and HOW will the Ummah get their questions responded to? The Sahaba (RA) were questioned in the same Haram and in the same Makkah which apparently you are now claiming gives amnesty to Shaykh Sudais (HA), this is deeply troubling.
There are many examples in Islam were people/leaders/Ulama were openly questioned, reprimanded and called to account PUBLICLY. As I said, I didn’t realise that we had become Catholics.
Imams of Haram can do whatever they like to whomever they like, back any coup, any treason, any settlement on Palestine, praise Donald Trump from the mimbar of Haram, fly to Pakistan and stop public uprising against Musharaf, give amnesty to Nawaz Sharif and then let him lose to inflict havoc on the Nation but the Ummah CANNOT even question an Imam of haram???
I said I had no clear position on the WAY to confront them, the evil of saudi actions is clear to all.
This cannot be undone and I am sure it will be greatly appreciated.