Yes everyone agree it's better at gome but some or rather many say it is categorically impermissible to come to the eid gah (and we're not even talking about massajid)
You have contributed 0.0% of this topic
Yes everyone agree it's better at gome but some or rather many say it is categorically impermissible to come to the eid gah (and we're not even talking about massajid)
Let me repeat what I have said multiple times.
As far as UK is concerned, majority of the Ulama know the local (council) regulations and the prevalent political culture so they are NOT stupid enough to advocate any such thing at all.
The issue of women attending Eidgah was caused by a visiting South African Shaykh who decided to insert himself into the local (city) situation and issued a Fatwa. His students/Mureeds (in UK) decided to oppose the local Ulama and called for a meeting. The meeting was leaked to the local Media and it became a closed meeting because a public issue. When the students/Mureeds of the South African scholar were confronted by the Media and the local Muslims, it became problematic for them to sustain their views.
“Concerned†is not from UK and has no local knowledge or facts to back up his crusade and clutches on straws to make his argument. There is no doubt that there are Ulama who hold the view of prohibition of women attending Mosques but they are minority to non-existent in UK.
If women are restricted in a UK Mosque, ONE PHONE CALL will get the Mosque shut down and the Charity investigated.
Older, non-English speaking Scholars visiting the West GET THIS POINT. People like “Concerned†and others DO NOT because it will pop their balloons.
Listen to Shaykh (Mufti) Saeed Ahmed Palanpuri (HA) in Urdu or English, he has grasped the issue...
www.central-mosque.com/index.php/General-Fiqh/womenmosque...
Translated...
Translated...
This cannot be undone and I am sure it will be greatly appreciated.
Please wait...