abu mohammed wrote:
View original post
Bhai, fatwa about congregational dua after Salah is the same. It is the same fatwa Mufti Ebrahim Saheb also gave. Mufti Ishaq Moosa Saheb wrote extensively upon it. But I still recall sitting in front of Mufti Ebrahim Saheb when he specifically told me that this particular answer must not be published without a disclaimer to administrators of masajid and the respective ulama to utilize hikmah in applying the ruling.
Not to use danda, rather a gradual soft tone of constant work to remove this habbit. Because the danda will bring about fitna and fitna is worse.
Mufti Sa'eed Saheb is equally harsh about digital photography, which is backed by majority deobandi mashayekh throughout the deobandi fraternity. Mufti Khanpuri Saheb strong and harsh wordings against those who took his photograph are still vibrating. The fiqhi stance of making ijtima'i Qiyam al Layl is also wellknown from madhab and from our fatawa kutub, but still those who follow Hazrat Ml. Husain Madani rahimahullah do not wish to move away from their stance. These matters are not to be dealt with danda.. piyaar muhabbat se adabi aur ilmi usloob se baat ki jaye.
All the bigger Muftiyan are our elders. They have the right to lash out at us, be cross with us and at times even make a walk out. I still remember Sh Yunus Jaunpuri rh kicked out our Muhtamim Ml Madani rahimahulah out of his own car to walk to his own home. These are their usloob and ways of making islaahs in whatever capacity they feel will be better. But that does not mean that as the broader awaam we take these lashings and start delivering our own lashing to the our ulama'. Martabay aur akbariyat ka lihaaz malhooz rakhna chahiyay.
But I do agree, the strength of admonishment shows how passionate Hazrat must be in his stance. That is saying something. If I am constantly invited to location A where they do not even follow my advice, even for sake of muruwwah and feeling shy of being in my presence, then either I will stop going there, or if I feel they deserve my harsh words, I will lash out at them. I have this same policy about fahash kalami. You swear in my presence, I will leave your company or will stop associating with you.