Anyone?
You have contributed 0.0% of this topic
Anyone?
Asslamo Allaikum,
I would like to also add that it means NOTHING but Tassawuff means Suhba of Mashaykh and Imam Abu Haneefa (RA) obviously had great Suhba (companionship). Tassawuff today is significantly different to Tassawuff of thsoe days and the Silsilas didn't even exist in the time of Imam Abu Haneefa (RA)
Asslamo Allaikum,
I would like to also add that it means NOTHING but Tassawuff means Suhba of Mashaykh and Imam Abu Haneefa (RA) obviously had great Suhba (companionship). Tassawuff today is significantly different to Tassawuff of thsoe days and the Silsilas didn't even exist in the time of Imam Abu Haneefa (RA)
Wa alay kum as salaam.
If silsilah's didn't exists at that time, then it means there were no 'Shaikh's as such in the various tariqas, so there were only pious people he sought and kept company with.
Right?
Asslamo Allaikum,
I would like to also add that it means NOTHING but Tassawuff means Suhba of Mashaykh and Imam Abu Haneefa (RA) obviously had great Suhba (companionship). Tassawuff today is significantly different to Tassawuff of thsoe days and the Silsilas didn't even exist in the time of Imam Abu Haneefa (RA)
Wa alay kum as salaam.
Is silsilah's didn't exists at that time, then it means there were no 'Shaikh's as such in the various tariqas, so there were only pious people he sought and kept company with.
Right?
Yes and his teachers and Ulamah did their Tazkiyah. Its just like they did "Dawah" but never went out for 4 months, 40 days, 3 days etc.
No its the same situation. The noble Imams didn't go 4 months and didn't make Bay't to a Shaykh in SilSila so whats the difference?
He didn't go 4 months or 3 days and yet fulfilled the Amal of Dawah so any comments about that?
He didn't go 4 months or 3 days and yet fulfilled the Amal of Dawah so any comments about that?
Why is this leaning towards tabligh? Please?
He didn't go 4 months or 3 days and yet fulfilled the Amal of Dawah so any comments about that?
Why is this leaning towards tabligh? Please?
Because you are starting a subject to provoke people into thinking that if Imam Abu Haneefa (RA), Imam Shaf'ae (RA) weren't Bay't to someone (as recommended by Sufees today) and their Islah was done then why can't they accept that Islah can be done without Ba'yt
That's unfair provocation as those involved in Tableegh, Tassawuff, Jihad etc are all from the Ulamah of Deoband and we should respect and appreciate each other and not poke holes in each other’s areas.
These are all aspects of Deen which have evolved under Mushwara and consultation by Ulamah over 1400+ years.
Tableeghi Jamaat today IS NO WAY the same Tableegh which the Sahaba (RA) or the Imams did.
Tassawuff today IS NO WAY the same Tassawuff which the Sahaba (RA) or the Imams did.
Modes of learning Islam today ARE NO WAY the same which the Sahaba (RA) or the Imams had (your usage of an internet forum is an example of that)
But all of these have evolved over 1400+ years according to needs of the people and are neither impermissible and Haram and a person should join whoever he/she thinks to be most beneficial to his/her Aakhira
If its Tableeghi Jamaat, so be it.
If its Tassawuff Jamaat, so be it.
If its Internet Jamaat, so be it.
If its Darul-uloom Jamaat, so be it.
As long as the matter is being done after consultation with Ulamah and under their guidence.
Those who criticise Tableeghi Jamaat are wrong.
Those who criticise Tassawuff Jamaat in the same way are also wrong.
Already done.
Which "Ulamah" say this?
This cannot be undone and I am sure it will be greatly appreciated.
Please wait...
