wa alaikum assalam bro.
I didnot intend to criticise them.
I think that a da'ee should be more practicing than the person who is given dawat.
No such precondition exists in Islam whatsoever. Moreover, those in Tableegh are involved for the purpose of reformation (i.e. they are going out in Jamaat to reform their bad habits and change their lives to the Sunnah).
Their Dawat (as per the principles) should revolve the six principles, reminders and explanation of the six points are done all the time.
We live in a democracy so if it is your personal opinion devoid, separate and distinct from Islam or the principles of Tableeghi Jamaat then you are entitled to your opinions (of course).
Loading Qur'aan Verse
Do you order righteousness of the people and forget yourselves while you recite the Scripture? Then will you not reason?
You have changed your mind, which one of the statements do you wish to adhere to?
Statement 1:
I think that a da'ee should be more practicing than the person who is given dawat.
Statement 2:
Practically, if a daee doesn't practice upon what he preaches to others, his dawah isn't effective.
Before I answer you, do you realise that these are 3 separate statements? I will happy to give you an answer on my statement from Tableeghi Jamaat sources itself but I still do not understand as to what is your position?
Would you like for me to answer your question first and then will you clarify your point?
Your Statement 1:
I think that a da'ee should be more practicing than the person who is given dawat.
Your Statement 2:
Practically, if a daee doesn't practice upon what he preaches to others, his dawah isn't effective.
My Statement:
No such precondition exists in Islam whatsoever.
There is nobody upset to calm down. If you want a thread to yourself then stop others from posting, until this it is a public forum.
Nabi (Sallallaho Alaihe Wassallam) has stated that Anger is Haram so let us BOTH follow the Sunnah.
Let’s get back to the issue.
You are my brother and I will be happy to answer any questions which you put to me seeking clarification about what I write.
But first, please understand that we are both talking about two separate things.
I am saying that practising can action is not a condition or pre-requisite to Dawah in Islam or Tableeghi Jamaat.
This is different to both of your statements (whether they match or not), read them again.
Statement 1:
I think that a da'ee should be more practicing than the person who is given dawat.
Statement 2:
Practically, if a daee doesn't practice upon what he preaches to others, his dawah isn't effective.
Let me explain by another example.
Wudhu is a not a condition or pre-requisite to sleeping
You say, “It is a good idea and a source of blessing to be in the state of Wudhu before sleepingâ€
This is just an example do not get hung up about Wudhu.
Once you have calmly and collectively grasped that we are talking about two separate scenarios, I will be happy to clarify my position (as I have already said). We will even discuss the Tafseer of the verse of the Qur’aan which you have posted.
There is no reason for poison or rancour in an Academic discussion. I am not a scholar or a Nabi so you have the full right to disagree once you have understood that we are talking cross purposes and about two separate matters.
Calmly, collectively and diligently read and decipher this post and then react without passion and emotion. Log off and walk away if you have to clear your mind before reading this and understanding that we are talking about two separate issues.
A disagreement (based on our misunderstanding) does not make you or me a Kaafir, Faasiq or Faajir…We both remain Muslim and brothers.
Do you grasp what is being said? Take your time and ask as many questions as you want but do so without emotion and passion.
Once you have grasped the root cause of our disagreement, we can discuss the issue within the context of Tableeghi Jamaat which is the topic of this thread.
P.S: Unlike what Sister “bint e aisha†claims, the highlighting is not to insult or shout at you but to clearly mark out the salient points of this post so there is no misunderstanding about what I am trying to convey to the best of my human ability. Nevertheless, if you still believe that highlighting or using colours or BOLD is insulting or offensive even after my clarification….Take my apology as it is not my intention and I have made that clear again and again and again.
And my post does...
This cannot be undone and I am sure it will be greatly appreciated.
Please wait...