He is definitely not the Mufti-Azam of America as his Mureeds like to pronounce on the Internet.
He is also claimed to be Ibn Sireen Sani (second incarnation of Ibn Sireen) whatever that means.
He claims two PhD degrees from two institutes which don’t even give out PhDs.
Basically he is a dream merchant of America which would be an apt title.
Takhasus is good enough, he is claiming PhD which he is not.
Lets extend your analogy for a second.
If a person graduates with a MSc from a western university with a degree in Islamic theology, we are told that he (or she) is not an Alim (or Alimah) because the university of Glasgow is not authorised to issue a Dars-e-Nizami qualification if they teach the same set of books.
Takhasus is specialisation which isn’t a PhD. It isn’t a question of inferior/superior but factually inaccurate.
PhD is a specialised degree which is conferred upon by fulfilling certain requirements. I am not saying that people with PhD are smart or able or anything like that if the two institutes listed DO NOT confer this qualification for the person to list it as having received it.
No doubt the dream Merchant of America is probably an extremely smart, intelligent and capable person but its factually inaccurate to list degrees which are not conferred upon by the institution.
Now keep on arguing that this guy is a real medical Doctor
I agree but in this case he doesn't even have western education its just false imitation in this case.
Edited, what I am doing here :)
This cannot be undone and I am sure it will be greatly appreciated.