if you are trying to understand then put your emotions aside and read what i wrote in its context. i was pointing out that the difference between the 2 shaikhs may have been political so doesn't pose much of a problem if that was the case. whereas if tabligh jamaat claims to be divinely guided then the current divide is problematic and may not be put down to just a political divide as both factions cannot claim to be divinely guided unless people want to claim that the split itself is divinely guided. my personal thoughts on tabligh jamaat is not relevant here.
i can only go by my own experiences which were very intimate and extensive and spans over quite a few years. what most people see on the surface is not the same on the inside. i can start giving anecdotal evidence, but its not going to convince anyone if i cant provide hard evidence. i know what i heard and saw and i will never back down from it.
on the surface you are more or less correct, but their reality on the inside is different.