Muftisays Blogs Version 3.0.0 Blogs Home |Create Blog | Login    
Categories
 
Latest Blog Entries
 
Search this blog
 
Subscribe
Subscribe to abu mohammed's Blog
 
abu mohammed's Links
 
HalalAdverts Network
 

Related Categories: Taqleed

27
Oct
2010
» 27th October 2010
The Ahle Hadith Follow Fiqh, They just dont know it!
Tags:
» posted by abu mohammed on 27th October 2010 - 13 comments

13 Comments

28 Oct 2010
IP Logged
musaib
assalamualaikum
can i talk 2 u bro.
Blogger's Reply:
Waalaykum Salaam. These blogs are also on the forums, you can ask anything you like there, if thats Ok, otherwise you can put your comments on the blogs. I am fair and open to correction, I will publish every comment unless asked not to. I am not an Imam/Scholar or any thing like that. What ever I have put up on the blogs comes from scholars themselves. On a few occasions I refute the lies that are said about Islam and I try to give all the evidence I can. This particular Blog comes from: http://www.muftisays.com/forums/members-research-group/4421/answering-salafi-s-pdf-downloads.html And so do many of my other blogs. They all come from sources readily available to every one.
 
28 Oct 2010
IP Logged
abdul
Blogger's Reply:
Jazakallah for that, You have a valid point for number 2) and possibly part of 6), 11) Aameen must be said, but this doeant mean one must say it loud, You will need to read the thousand of other hadith availabe. 12) says "will the Salah be Valid" not "what beaks the Salah". 20) Dua is mentioned in many Hadith narrated by Aisha (ra). The Prophet used to pray Allahuma antas salam..... Shaykhs like Albani have ommited many Hadith from the Sahihs and because of this, there is so much fitna amongst the muslims. Why did he have to do that. The Imams of hadith were IMAMS of HADITH. They went through tuff rules before accepting the Hadith. like I said, I got it from books written by prominent scholars. The problem with the Salafi is that evolve. They quote ibn Taymiyyah to prove Taraweeh is 8 rakaats, then they quote him again to confirm it is 20 rakats. Its a mess. Joining Salah together is only done in Hajj. The narrations for the combinning of the Salah are when the end time of zohar comes, zohar is prayed and immediatley when asar time starts, asar is prayed. same thing for maghrib and isha, they are prayed at the end time of maghrib and beginnig time of Isha. Simply reading a Hadith doesnt answer all the questions. One needs to read the countless others to come to a decission, The fuqaha have done this for us. Imam Bukhari only wrote approx 7000 hadith in his book, but he knew over 700,000 hadith. He even said that the Hadith he has left out far exceed the number he has written in his book. Try reading the Muwatta of Imam Muhammad, Kitab al Aathar of Imam Abu Hanifa, Al Hidayyah of Hanafi fiqh written over 800 years ago. You will be suprised to see Hadith in there, that, if you mention them to the Salafis, they will say its fabricated, SubhanAllah. The Salafi preacher, Dr Zakir Naik always quotes Sahih Bukhari and says that you must say Aameen loudly. It doesnt even say that in Sahih bukhari. The word Loud or "JAHR" is not used in the arabic version. And I heard this from someone who teaches Hadith for a living. Although the word loud is used in other Hadith. Dr Naik misquotes or half quotes and misleads the Muslims on issues of Fiqh. He should stick to comparative religion or medicine.
 
29 Oct 2010
IP Logged
Pharmf886
Hello! kekbdke interesting kekbdke site!
Blogger's Reply:
Sorry, cant make any sense of what is being said.
 
11 Nov 2010
IP Logged
ashrafshaikhh
Blogger's Reply:
Jazakallah, for your long reply. When I first saw these statements I knew that they were wrong, any one would be able to point out most of them from the Hadith. I think that the article points to those fools who think they know what they are talking about and only quote Sahih Bukhari as their source of guidance. It is a wake up call. Like the last person you havent commented on points 6,7,8 etc. Dont worry we all follow someone in everything we do. You may not be Jahil like me, but I pray to Allah that he takes YOU out from where you think I am. Tum Salafus Saliheen ki baat karte hu aur inki hi baat nahi mante. Yeh post tu sirf eik dekhawa hai tume pass bolane ke liye. Agar tum sub kuch paro ge to InshaAllah tum apna irada badal do ge. (Sorry I dont know Urdu/Hindi very well). Main manta hu ke yeh bekar points hai, lekin aur bhi bohat sare posts hai, is me bhi dekho. Darna mat, Allah tumhare sath hai. Agar mene kuch bhi ghalat bola hu, tu please mujhe maaf karna, meri yeh niyat nahi thi. Aur aap ku to mene maaf kar hi diya hai, so dont worry. Allah hum sub ku Hidayat de, Aameen. Rahee salafus saleheen ki baat, tum sub Hazrat Umar ki baat taal dete hu, Kyu? Shia ho? Nahi na, tu fir kyu Hazrat Umar ki Sunnat nahi apna te ho? A Hadith states that Rasulullaah (SAW) said, “Verily Allaah has placed the truth on the tongue of Umar.”(1) This tells us that nothing contrary to the truth will come from the tongue of Hadhrat Umar (RA). Therefore, why should he not be a criterion for good and bad? There is also another narration in which Rasulullaah (SAW) said, “There has been Muhaddathoon in the previous nations (people whose tongues are inspired with the truth). If there is any Muhaddath in my Ummah, it is definitely Umar.”(2) Imaam Tahtaawi (RH) reports a Hadith in which Rasulullaah (SAW) says, “Many things will be initiated after me and those that I love the most are the ones that Umar shall initiate. You people should therefore adhere steadfastly to that which Umar initiates.”(3) 1) Tirmidhi, as quoted in Mishkaatul Masaabeeh (Pg.554). 2) Mishkaatul Masaabeeh (Pg.554). 3) Imaam Tahtaawi (RH)’s commentary to Maraaqil Falaah, Pg.239. SubhanAllah, look at the third Hadith. How many times have we heard that Taraweeh is 8 Rakaats, it was Umar(RA) who introduced 20 rakaats. And how many times have we said that we must follow the Sunnah of The Khulafa e Rashideen. We hear the same thing about Talaq by the same people, they say that it was Umar who said 3 talaqs is 3 not 1 talaq. SubhanAllah! Aap ke liye mene Ahsaan kar diya hai, please waqt mile tu is me zarur dekh na. Salaam, (Suche Dil se, Jahilu ki tarah nahin) http://www.muftisays.com/blog/abu+mohammed/553_09-11-2010/the-way-or-not-the-way-of-the-salaf..html. Please, jis subject pe Aap ku jawab dena ho, tu please usme hi dena. Aur please angrezi me likho ge tu sub par sakte hai, Sawal ku repat karne ki bhi zarurat nahin hai. Shukriyah
 
1 Jan 2011
IP Logged
Wajahat Hussain
Asslam Alaikum Abu Mohammad Bhai.
Can just give me reference of this saying
"it was Umar who said 3 talaqs is 3 not 1 talaq."
Jazakallah
Blogger's Reply:
Funny you ask for References. It is the best thing to do. I have herad it in many talks by prominent Scholars and teachers of Hadith. It is even in Sahih Bukhari that 3 is 3 and not 1 talaq. It is mostly from the Salafi or other Ghair Muqallids who say that it is the opinion of Umar (RA), then they say that this the reason for not accepting it. Allahu Allum. By the way, PLEASE NOTE, I AM NOT AN IMAM OR MUFTI OR SCHOLAR. JAZAKALLAH. The Q & A section has answers by Muftis. Jazakallah once again for taking the time out to read and reply to my blog.
 
1 Jan 2011
IP Logged
Wajahat Hussain
Blogger's Reply:
I agree with you, but these Quran verses and Hadith are for a single divorce. Please also see the Hadith regarding Umar(ra). and the Hadith about following the Sunnah of the Khulafa. http://www.muftisays.com/blog/abu+mohammed/571_17-11-2010/the-way-or-not-the-way-of-the-salaf..html See number 63.
 
12 Feb 2011
IP Logged
Pharmg201
Hello! fbgdeed interesting fbgdeed site!
 
19 Jul 2012
IP Logged
Imran
Sir i want to Know is it True That Fardz rakaat is not mention in Sahi hadeeth ....
 
19 Jul 2012
IP Logged
Imran
Sir i want to Know is it True That Fardz rakaat is not mention in Sahi hadeeth ....
Blogger's Reply:
Jazakallahu Khair for reading and replying. I am not a scholar, therefore it is best to ask questions to the scholars of Hadith. You may want to ask them here http://www.muftisays.com/qa/ or elsewhere. I simply put forward the works of other scholars. Jazakallahu Khairan.
 
28 Dec 2013
IP Logged
ahlulhadith
Salam Alaykum brother. Who told you that the Ahlul hadith do not follow fiqh? I am a Ahlul hadith myself, and have been learned that we do follow fiqh. So actually, your whole article is of no use, because it is based upon a misconception.
 
11 May 2014
IP Logged
Usman Ali
Ahle hadit follow Ibne Adnul Wahabi Najdi
Who is Horn Of Satan. They are Wahabi najidi
Blogger's Reply:
I'm not impressed with such comments, especially about the deceased. Coming from a place called Najd doesn't necessarily mean that everyone from there is a Najdi from the horn of Shaitan. Many people have erred in their lifetime, and we ask Allah to forgive them and forgive us of our sins. For all we know, these people mmay have been much better than us.
 
26 May 2014
IP Logged
zaqam
You are saying you are not scholar , then why the hell are you doing this. Don't make people fool one day you will become foolish.
Blogger's Reply:
Salaam, yes I'm not a scholar, but I've simply reproduced the work of the scholars so its more accessible to the likes of us laypeople
 
14 Dec 2014
IP Logged
Syed Umair Umar
ALHAMDULILLAH i am AHLEHADITH and we pray Salaah like Muslims prays in MASJID AN NABWI, MASID AL HARAM. We Pray Salaah like Imam of Kaaba prays Salaah. You should first see how witr are performed in Saudi Arabia.
 
1 May 2015
IP Logged
k. m. najib
What is mentioned above is wrong, infect, everything is performed following authentic hadedth, that is why these people are known as AHLE HADEDTH
Ma Allah guide us
 

Write a comment
(required) - not published nor available to blogger
(click and type the word shown)