Muadh_Khan's Blog

12
Jul
2016
Dr Zakir Naik, India & Deobandees
12th July 2016

In the Name of Allah, the Most Gracious, the Most Merciful.

As-salāmu ‘alaykum wa-rahmatullāhi wa-barakātuh

Background:

  1. On July 1st 2016 a group of Terrorists targetted and killed civilians in Dhaka (Bangladesh). Rohan Imtiaz (22) one of the Terrorists was found to have some Facebook posts of Dr Zakir Naik.
  2. DailyStar of Bangladesh started the ball rolling and the Indian Media jumped into the frenzy. DailyStar of Bangladesh has now issued a tame apology
  3. But the Indian Media and even the Prime Minister have Joined in the chorus.
  4. Indian Media has come across Fatwaas of Deobandees during their search for any dirt against Dr Zakir Naik and they are using it to spice their stories. Darul-uloom Deoband has condemened their actions.

Story keep on rolling...

Analysis & Solution:

I have been saying this for over 10 years that the solution to “Dr Zakir Naik”’s problem is not to issue Fatwaas. They do stop some people from accessing him but for the vast majority of Muslims he is working for Islam while other groups are issuing Fatwaas. In the eyes of laymen, Dr Zakir Naik wins.

The solution is actually very simple but needs dedication and discipline.

The solution is to develop Deobandi capabilities which are professional, competent enough to lure people in and compete.

For hundreds of years, Deobandees have relied on name recognition and they expect people to still be lured by names.

Media has changed the equation.  Before the Media equation it was the Printing Press which changed things in India.

  1. Sir Syed Ahmed Khan (RA)
  2. Maulana Maududi (RA)
  3. Dr Israr Ahmed (RA)
  4. Dr Zakir Naik

What do all these people have in common? Deobandees warned masses against them and you can see the diminishing returns as the grasp of Ulama upon laymen loosened.

Posting Fatwaas or Malfoozat (sayings) of Ulama won’t achieve the change which Deobandees require because the brand recognition is now working against them.

100 year ago masses knew Shaykhuk-Hind (RA) and not many knew Maulana Maududi (RA).

Today masses know Dr Zakir Naik and how many people even know the name of Principle of Darul-uloom Deoband?

It has been over 10 years, I have been saying the same thing again and again and again.

Take a good look at the websites, blogs of Deobandees from India. Do you honestly see any comparison to the presentation of Dr Zakir Naik?

Dr Zakir Naik has (multiple) TV channels reaching masses while the Deobandees of India have badly done websites displaying talks, speeches and books of Hazrats.

The prime example is the website http://attablig.com/ run by my dear friend and elder (Maulana) Abu Uzair (DB).

I know that Dr Zakir Naik is a professional and probably has access to a very good legal team so this will end sooner or later.

But the issue of Deobandees won’t go away. In fact Dr Zakir Naik’s popularity has soared due to this and the day is not far when Deobandees will appear on his platform simply because Dr Zakir Naik and he Media Machine will have ground down the opposition.

Scholars like my dear friend and elder (Maulana) Abu Uzair (DB) don’t seem to understand that, at all. He is a young, dynamic Indian Scholar so if he doesn’t understand the equation what chance do older Ulama have who are a generation removed from the current fast-paced media world?

Deobandees by issuing statements in favour of Dr Zakir Naik have actually shot themselves in the foot because these positive statements would be used against their Fatwaas. It will be very difficult to convince Indian (laymen) that we supported him in his hour of need but we disagree with him on factual grounds.

STRATEGY for Deobandees (in India and elsewhere) should be work 24 hours a day 365 days a week and develop their own capabilities. Ignore Dr Zakir Naik and build their capabilities. Improve their PR machine and delivery.

You will see dividends in a few months.

Deobandees in the West are similarly being affected by Dr Yasir Qadhi and Numan Ali Khan etc. This is also due to slick delivery and professionalism. Deobandees tried to issue Fatwaas but it backfired (mostly) because Muslims in the West hate this sort of targeting so now we see Deobandees posting their material. The distinction has been eroded and again the resistance has been ground down.

Sooner or later, it will happen in India. It will happen in Indian universities and professional circles and then masses (if it has not already happened).

posted by Muadh_Khan on 12th July 2016 - 4 comments

4 Comments

12 Jul 2016
IP Logged
Abu Hafsa
I'm too crying for this. The magnetism of Salafis and their institutions in their digital marketing is very powerful that it can attract any educated and non-educated person. Look at their websites, pamphlets, e-pamphlets, posters, videos, images, etc.

Everything looks very stunning that it can give very clear message to the passerby. Salafis concentrate more on English language and if they ever have to use Urdu in their shows, they are so simple to understand. Many of the words use in the 'Ulema's lectures are very difficult to understand for today's youth. Reading Urdu is very far from this.

Whenever there are any big jalsa of Deobandiees, they begin posting big posters (no quality at all) and that too in Urdu language. Those posters fills with the names of 'Ulema-e-ikram that I can say 90% of the people who will look at it don't even know 2-3 scholars.

Look at the side of Ghayr Muqallideen. Their posters have quality, colorful, no hadhrath's name mentioned (except the lecturer'ss name), and title of the lecture in English. This is the case of my place.

 
17 Jul 2016
IP Logged
ahamed sharif
Presently there are two types of presenting deen
1. Through loud speeches
2. Through dars.
In first type there are possibilities that we can be "joe uthaa lay uska bachcha hogaya". So called Beauty, glamour, presentation style comes under this category.
In the first type Mind can changes dynamically.
In second type, words get embedded into our mind and no external force can erase that.

Today Presentation through media comes under 1st category.
What Deoband and its cadres are following is the 2nd type. Alhamdulillah for more than 100 years it has yielded the BEST results. Deen could face challenges in all times.

In fact, the 1st type is alive because of ground work by Deoband cadres.

To conclude, if one believes in glamour, zeal, cosmetics etc. they have the first choice.

And first group cannot execute activities of deoband but deoband can (if really required) can execute activities of the first group.
 
17 Jul 2016
IP Logged
ahamed sharif
Who is a deobandee?
Are the ulema who are in the present madrasah.
OR ulema who have graduated from deoband
OR brothers who follow the deobandee manhaj.

Salafism is not spreading through its core members, everyone who follows their manhaj gives his 100%. And offers his full energy and his resources. All the resources on web are product of individual contributions.

But

A deobandee demands payments to translate the best literature in urdu by the best ulema to english (to counter the fitnahs). Or demands royalty to republish books or booklets.

No win situation!!
 
20 Jul 2016
IP Logged
Mohammed Asif
Masha Allah
Reality well analysed.....and right to the core.

Muadh sb can I have your email I'd plzzzz
Blogger's Reply:
www.central-mosque.com
 
4 Aug 2016
IP Logged
moinudeen
recent allegation on zakir naik is due to politics of undermining dawah activities by him. I understand Zakir naik is not qualified to give fatwah. At this time of dire need, it is the responsibility of scholars should raise against these political allegations [raised against muslims like Dr.zakir naik] by anti-muslim stand govt. We have to discuss our ideological differences within us and it should be discussed within us to sort that out. it is not necessary to show that to public.
Blogger's Reply:
Has Dr Zakir Naik "discussed" ideological differences behind closed doors or blasted Muslims (whom he disagrees) with on Camera?
 
Write a comment
(required) - not published nor available to blogger